Previously: Episode 1 (Nathaniel) Episode 2 (Spencer) Episode 3 (Lynn)
Let's face it. This fucking lie has had quite a shelf life.
by Nathaniel R
I can't be the only person to have made this observation but occasionally Big Little Lies is rather like a high-end version of Desperate Housewives. There are the core group of women who maybe wouldn't be friends in real life but whose distinctive personalities make a juicy combustible mix as a cast (within the alloted tight geographically region: cul de sac in one case, beachfront in the other) Didn't Housewives also have a crime or murder mystery each season to mix in with the soap opera theatrics? At any rate, it's worth mentioning because the writing on Big Little Lies this season is... questionable. It's not a patch on the first season cumulatively, alas, but scene by scene it's still great evening entertainment in the old tradition of the "watercooler" show; it certainly gives us a lot to talk about!
In this episode, Mary Louise (Meryl Streep) makes her big move -- suing Celeste (Nicole Kidman) for custody of "her boys". That's the huge story beat that will undoubtedly take us through to the finale (episode 7) but it's more like a prologue this time around as the bulk of the episode deals with 1) Amabella's birthday party 2) Madeleine and Ed's flailing marriage, and 3) the bizarre 'are they really going there?' subplot of Bonnie's mom having a stroke while also possibly being psychic and predicting that Bonnie will drown. We suspect everyone in the writer's room of Big Little Lies wore matching Regina George"A Little Bit Dramatic" t-shirts while they wrote "She Knows"
Top Ten MVPs of Big Little Lies, Episode 2.4: “She Knows”
Today is Amabella's day and it will be filled with laugher and magic and pure unimitigated joy.
10 Renata's Happy-Face Act / and the Disco Party
Dern's performance may have gotten broader this season, but there's a method to the madness. Renata is coming undone and since she's always performing for others rather than just being, the performance is more and more naked. She's now moved from forced 'fake it til you make it' style cheer to outright hostile reality-warping.
It's the best pizza in the world.
09 Meryl and Pizza
We thank Big Little Lies for this reprise of one of our favourite Oscar moments.
08 Uh-oh
Bonnie's angry charge towards the detective in the hospital. This scene is but a split second long but what a doozy... and there will obviously be repercussions in episode 5.
07 Nicole's Ambien Face
This storyline is dumb but nobody does emptied-out befuddlement like Nicole. No one. (See also Birth and The Others.) Plus we're happy that Celeste finally got some again. (Cute bartender!)
06 [TIE] Reese's Pause / Streep's Shoulder Shrug
The single most entertaining thing about Season 2 has been the intermittent reminders of Madeline and Mary Louise's hate-at-first-sight status. The battle continues. Reese's agressive head-nodding "mmmhmmm" at the doorway, forcing Mary Louise to awkwardly invite herself in, and Streep's shrug when Madeline later asks "Is that your hint for me to leave?" were both hilarious.
Is that supposed to be funny?
05 Opposites. "Next we're going to do synonyms".
Hinged/Unhinged. I died. Chloe (Darby Camp) is the most underrated character on the show and Madeline absolutely deserves having her as a daughter. Discuss.
04 Madeline & Ed at Odds
Reese Witherspoon and Adam Scott are fleshing out this marital divide with true panache. Each of their four scenes together in this episode -- proposing marriage counselling, discussing Madeline's charged personality, talking about Ed's emotional absence, or the tetchy disco party exchange (Ed is completely correct in his assessment of that scene but he's also being a total dick which gives the scene a provocative real-life charge). Marital divides are never black and white situations but filled with thickly complex agendas, hurts, truths, and questionable motivations.
03 Zoe Kravitz in general
We've been waiting for the show to give her the kind of meat to chew on that the other women have gotten and we're finally getting it. If Nicole is the MVP of Season 1, and Reese the MVP overall, then Zoe is the MVP of this particular episode. Watch they way she keeps shuffling through emotions, from scene to scene and shot to shot. Her scenes in the hospital are amazingly raw, but her fluidity in the dance scene with her mother who she's always so guarded around was a sight to behold as well.
02 Renata vs. Bankruptcy Officer
LIVING FOR THIS STARE DOWN. So much privilege and hostility. But Renata has finally met her match. The trustee is having none of her white nonsense. We thank the actor John Marshall Jones for his enormously satisfying refusal to be intimidated. He's the first character since Madeline herself that Renata isn't remotely able to bulldoze.)
01 SLAPPING MERYL
Three cheers for Celeste for finally letting Mary Louise have it in full Dynasty prime time soap opera fashion. And three cheers to Meryl for absolutely killing this scene from beat one to its cruel finale. Watch the way she enters the scene with eyes comically wide with innocence (though this woman is fully aware of what she's doing) which is more than a little aggressive. It only crescendos from there with a direct provocation before the slap.
"What do we call that?... foreplay?" Meryl lets us know that Mary Louise knows she's cut Celeste to the bone with a hugely inappropriate giggle as she walks out of camera range. The giggle is ostensibly directed at her grandsons as she slips the fun grandmother face back on with the ease of a consummate manipulator, but it's also salt thrown backwards into a fresh wound.
I'd argue that "She Knows" was the weakest of Season 2's episodes thus far and this is largely why -- it had no where to go but down from this excellent scene at the beginning of the episode.