Review: "Black Panther: Wakanda Forever"

Sunday

Nov202022

Sunday, November 20, 2022 at 11:40AM

by Nathaniel R

Presenting a task as impossible as hiding a futuristic country for centuries in Sub-Saharan Africa. Imagine having to follow up the phenomenon of Marvel's Black Panther (2018) which, like most explosive zeitgeist events, had ultra precise perfectly timed ingredients and arrived at the exact moment in culture when all of them would be most appreciated. Now imagine having to follow that up without its charismatic leading man, lost to cancer at the young peak of an already impressive career. Director Ryan Coogler was in an unenviable position. It's no surprise, then, that the sequel to Marvel's most popular solo adventure is a bit wobbly on arrival. Never mind that the sequel must bear the weight of all the absurd expectations and make sense of T'Challa's absence while trying to find new legs on both land AND at sea. Thank god for the latter. Whatever the movie's faults, it's not from attempting a simplistic retread...

Most of Wakanda Forever's best scenes are courtesy of its new antagonist Namor (Tenoch Huerta). In a thematically cohesive rethinking of the underwater comic book origins, the antihero is no longer Namor the Submariner of Atlantis but the "feathered serpent god" ruler of the underwater kingdom of Talokan. What stays the same is that he's referred to as a mutant (the Marvel Cinematic Universe is slowly opening the doors to let the entire X-Men collective in). In other words, the Talokan citizens may be powerful in battle but they can't fly and don't have super-strength to rival that of the Hulk as their leader does. Talokan makes a neat (too neat?) parallel to Wakanda in that it's also a scientifically advanced society / utopia that's remained utterly hidden from the world... until now.

As we discover in the first act, alongside a stunned Queen Ramonda (Angela Bassett) and Princess Shuri (Letitia Wright), Talokan has its own stockpile of Vibranium. Namor, in point of fact, is covered in it. Well, as covered in it as you can be when your costume is a green swim suit and the Vibranium is your accessories.

This early reveal is the film's smartest narrative rug-pull, instantly levelling the playing field. When your heroes are all-powerful like Superma -- a DC problem that's now infecting Marvel as the heroes become ever more godlike -- you gotta pull out the Kryptonite! While Namor is used somewhat sparingly, Huerta makes the most of his screen time with a mesmerizing masculine glower, as confident about his own certain victory as the Wakandas are accustomed to feeling about themselves in any battle. But no more. Namor offers Wakanda a deal that's more of a threat and the film is finally off to the races. (It takes so long for superhero films to get going these days though in this case, it's more excusable as the film had to narrativize T'Challa's absence.)

From Namor's entrance forward, though, it's more of the same as Marvel features go. As per usual there are questionable and uneven visual effects. Narratively the typical Marvel problems appear like rushed character intros that accept your enthusiasm without working for it (Riri Williams is to Wakanda Forever exactly what America Chavez was to Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness). Marvel Studios tend to favor episodic plottiness to structural elegance or complex characterizations and that is also emphatically true here. And finally, from at least the Sokovian Accords onward, the thematic ambitions of this sprawling series of films always end up at war with the realities of fantasy-escapism franchises. Wakanda Forever wants to be about the evils and legacy of colonialism -- all the wealthy countries on Earth want the resources of Wakanda and Talokan and are prepared to aggressively take them -- but it's not as if the fictional heroes in a Hollywood superhero picture are going to declare war on the very real countries where their fans live.

Director Ryan Coogler tries valiantly to make this all work and it does here and there. In the end his considerable gifts are arguably better suited to grounded human drama than superhero pictures. It's why Creed remains both his best film and the one with his best-directed action sequences. That's surely why the persistent human heart of Wakanda Forever is heard most clearly in its mother/daughter sequences in which opposing points of view are more exciting than any of the messy battle lines between Wakandans and their new Talokan enemies. It's also why the single best action moment is a small character beat in a flurry of violence. A cut from undefeatable Namor in surprised agony to a close up of one his bloody feathers in Black Panther's claws is pure movie magic, however brief.

The plot vs its politics and the funereal tone were unavoidable given the circumstances of the sequel and the original film. But there's still a hole at the film's center that's not healed. Letitia Wright is a solid actor and handles the dramatic demands of the grief drama well, but sadly she lacks the effortless movie star magnetism of a Chadwick Boseman or a Lupita Nyong'o (who is sadly sidelined again -- but what a sideline!) or even arguably a Winston Duke (who is lively fun again as M'Baku). While Black Panther Wakanda Forever has strong beats they rarely linger and the film doesn't flow and build from scene to scene as great movies tend to. Given the disappointment, eternal blessings to its twin MVPs for keeping the sequel on its feet and even lifting off a few times: The dynamic duo of actress Angela Bassett and costume designer Ruth E Carter. Both of these remarkable screen talents are experts at heightened registers. Together they sell the operatic narrative grief and the engaging high-fantasy patriotism of Wakanda in inspired stylish union. B-/C+

NATHANIEL R | Sold Out Show |

Permalink |

Email This

tagged

Angela Bassett,

Black Panther Wakanda Forever,

superheroes

View Printer Friendly Version

Email Article to Friend

Reader Comments (9)

I'd like to contribute but these big noisy sfx driven films leave me stone cold,love Bassett though,glad you liked it.

November 20, 2022 |

Mr Ripley79

A fine analysis. Your love for film shows strongly here.

November 20, 2022 |

Finbar McBride

What a perfect comparison between the characters Riri Williams and America Chavez! You are exactly right.

Although the actors playing Shuri and Riri are fine, I don’t have much interest in their further adventures. The Wakanda continuing actors that I would like to see more of are Lupita Nyong’o, Winston Duke, and Danai Gurira. (And Angela Bassett...).

Although it looks like it will have more huge box office, some commentators have said since it isn’t as good as the first film, it can’t be considered for Best Picture. I would disagree.

If the aim is to have box office successes (that are also good movies) on the Best Picture slate to revive general Oscar interest, I’d say, why not go for 6?
Avatar 2, Wakanda Forever, Maverick, Everything Everywhere, The Woman King, The Glass Onion.

That still leaves 4 for loved and respected movies that don’t make a lot of money.

November 20, 2022 |

McGill

Nathaniel, I agree with a lot you say and yet I still liked the movie better than you did and in some ways better than the first BP, which I enjoyed and admired but didn't love quite as much as most.

As a Marvel product, WF isn't one of the best; the VFX are meh and the plotting is pretty indifferent, even slipshod at times, and as you point out, thematically not the most coherent. There are some intriguing threads that are underexplored and others that feel totally superfluous (like every scene with Julia Louis-Dreyfus and Martin Freeman). But as a tribute to T'Challa - and Chadwick Boseman - I thought it was really moving and effective. And I thought Namor was one of the most compelling...not villains...adversaries I've seen so far in a Marvel movie, even more compelling than Michael B. Jordan's Killmonger. (Even if his conflict with Wakanda/Shuri felt both forced and not so much resolved as cut off without much reason except the movie had to get there.)

And I also have to disagree slightly about Letitia Wright, who exceeded my expectations as Shuri. She had some heavy lifting to do, and admittedly she didn't do it alone, what with the bevy of compelling ladies surrounding her. But she rose to the occasion nicely. A lot of the power of her performance was exactly her grappling with how difficult it was to fill that huge hole left behind by T'Challa/Boseman. It's reflected in the choices Shuri makes in the final scene(s). And in the stinger, though that may also have been the studio giving themselves an out in light of Wright's offscreen...issues.

(Speaking of which - side note/SPOILER: while I was grateful for the stinger's explaining Nyong'o's character's inexplicable absence, I was a little annoyed at the implication that in the end, Wakanda needs another T'Challa. The patriarchy is dead, long live the patriarchy!)

November 20, 2022 |

Lynn Lee

https://flip.it/lTVT61
https://flip.it/9SYCRt
https://flip.it/NB8VG9
https://flip.it/C4iSXM
https://flip.it/B9MtrF
https://flip.it/ciujIk
https://flip.it/AgbepN
https://flip.it/wq9l58
https://flip.it/FaabHL
https://flip.it/5iSw8E
https://flip.it/M_vDVb
https://flip.it/6X_zaT
https://flip.it/7F7pVa
https://flip.it/OgG3xx
https://flip.it/or_4yj
https://flip.it/VNGjrR
https://flip.it/_C4CpT
https://flip.it/EvAYmW
https://flip.it/ZsfqmG
https://flip.it/Hhq47v
https://flip.it/EzATm_
https://flip.it/0DtSY7
https://flip.it/L94EMl
https://flip.it/q.k0k1
https://flip.it/pyn4f-
https://flip.it/Op.8zO
https://flip.it/Pmsmp1
https://flip.it/2SQb52
https://flip.it/vGDDeH
https://flip.it/TtRtvg
https://flip.it/ngQVRH
https://flip.it/zbQ3OM
https://flip.it/vZvelc
https://flip.it/uUf-vT
https://flip.it/Dmc-xP
https://flip.it/z5meHk
https://flip.it/siVmAF
https://flip.it/F7.yxl
https://flip.it/rJQt2t
https://flip.it/Hmfia3
https://flip.it/mPVqAZ
https://flip.it/HjgNBK
https://flip.it/lyscFr
https://flip.it/oMA_sM
https://flip.it/zA__g-
https://flip.it/kDWN1k
https://flip.it/_a044O
https://flip.it/SYTlGd
https://flip.it/DNYgIe
https://flip.it/io4VNA
https://flip.it/MbGI_Q
https://flip.it/MxmuHD
https://flip.it/UEqhDR
https://flip.it/tE43k7
https://flip.it/n-Y9Ps
https://flip.it/k0SovO
https://flip.it/zZ0nYj
https://flip.it/1u9IEN
https://flip.it/iawUQU
https://flip.it/VnW9tU
https://flip.it/mxGK6F
https://flip.it/0TE.0d
https://flip.it/kCF68s
https://flip.it/lNITk_
https://flip.it/5jk5lH
https://flip.it/QoGEph
https://flip.it/ikEv0Z
https://flip.it/gQhrw4
https://flip.it/l1GBKy
https://flip.it/51QJQn
https://flip.it/-vrAjA
https://flip.it/Hu82nE
https://flip.it/f0hQ6G
https://flip.it/UZuG5T
https://flip.it/z-Of2j
https://flip.it/_vxyoi
https://flip.it/hDOrOk
https://flip.it/BqObPf
https://flip.it/hlkgWT
https://flip.it/Abu85A
https://flip.it/Kw07ke
https://flip.it/BEmHB0
https://flip.it/8yPHBz
https://flip.it/perY2H
https://flip.it/M.WklW
https://flip.it/3nLFOp
https://flip.it/hj6Drt
https://flip.it/fMirqS
https://flip.it/U2Nf2e
https://flip.it/CqamIp