Review: All Quiet on the Western Front
Wednesday, November 2, 2022 at 9:47AM By Christopher James
Paul Bäumer (Felix Kammerer) heads into World War I in "All Quiet on the Western Front," the German submission this year for Best International Feature.
It’s daunting to remake a Best Picture winner. Steven Spielberg was able to breathe new life and vitality into West Side Story, making it a companion to the timeless original. But, more often than not, filmmakers buckle under the weight of expectations and self importance (like the failures of, say, Steven Zaillian's star-studded rendition of All the King’s Men or Timur Bekmambetov's Ben-Hur).
The Lewis Milestone adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque's anti-war novel All Quiet on the Western Front in 1930 struck new ground for realism, brutality and anti-war sentiments. It earned Oscar wins for Best Picture and Best Director. It's been regarded as a classic ever since, later receiving citations on AFI’s list of best films and best epics and inclusion in the National Film Registry. How could a new film pack a similar punch? Director Edward Berger doesn’t reinvent the story, but his 2022 re-telling of All Quiet on the Western Front is loaded with enough technical panache to make it a worthy, additive remake and a great time at the movies...
Paul (Felix Kammerer) finds an ally in a jovial, older soldier named Kat (Albrecht Schuch).We open in 1917 Germany. The hottest party in town is the line to enlist to fight in World War I, which has raged for three years at this point. Our 17-year-old warrior twink, Paul Bäumer (Felix Kammerer), pulls the age-old trick of faking his age and mother’s signature in order to enlist with his friends. Paul and his friends are overjoyed, as if they are signing up for a fraternity. These bright smiles are quickly dashed not by some angry drill sergeant, but by immediate action in the trenches. Death was not late to the wartime onboarding session.
As the war wages on, the movie splits into two storylines - Paul and friends dodging death from every angle, and German officer Matthias Erzberger (Daniel Brühl) negotiating an armistice with the Allied powers. This juxtaposition further dramatizes the bloodshed at the hands of the bureaucracy of war. The Germans know full well that the war has not shaken out in their favor. However, they want one last wing in their neverending chase for glory. Due to the arguing at the top levels, Paul and his friends must survive through more and more challenging and bloody battles at the front. And what for? They have national pride, but no vested interest in a cause they’re fighting for. They fight for their country, but never ask why they fight for their country.
Daniel Brühl enters the film to argue for peace, but finds himself stalled while men die around him.This internal conflict is all over Kammerer’s face, as he leads the film with grace. Much of the performance is wide-eyed horror; yet, he finds the subtleties within those broad strokes. As the war ends, the central friend group really gets to show their range. Battered, wounded and clinging onto faint bits of hope, the group looks forward to the end while realizing their time on the battlefield is not necessarily over. In particular, Albrecht Schuch stands out as an older, live-wire soldier named Kat who takes Paul and his friends under his wings. He soon learns that war has other plans. Age does not make it easier to withstand the traumas that befall all soldiers.
The film is filled with many bold stylistic choices. Composer Volker Bertelmann’s score blares as our characters make their way into the trenches. It recalls a Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross score bumped up to 10 with heavy synth. There’s something aurally overpowering about it. Though it may not be everyone’s cup of tea, I enjoyed how dissonant and modern it sounded contrasted with this age old story.
War is horrifyingly rendered in director Edward Berger's take on the classic novel and film.The cinematography by James Friend balances beauty with horror. Looking at trailers and stills, one gets the impression that the color palette is nothing more than fifty-plus shades of gray. However, Friend manages to capture bits of beauty as he dramatizes the overwhelming scale of war. One particularly exhilarating sequence introduces tanks as they emerge from the fog towards the German trenches. The camera simultaneously is in awe of these vessels of destruction and fearfully stunned as they approach our protagonists.
Here's one final critique that has very little to do about the film itself, but is more about the state of distribution and the Netflix elephant in the room. This film deserves to be seen in a theater, at least by those who would like to appreciate it. The sound shakes the seats. The glints of color among the clouds shine beautifully bright. Berger has created an immersive experience, not unlike Sam Mendes’ recent hit 1917 or Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk. All that is to say, when watching at home turn the phone off, turn the lights off and give yourself over to one of the more beautiful films of the year. B+
All Quiet on the Western Front is now playing in select theaters and streaming on Netflix.
Reader Comments (4)
Nice review, Christopher. I liked the film but had a lot more reservations than you did (it's a B– or C+ for me). You're right that the music wouldn't be everyone's cup of tea because it certainly wasn't mine. I was also reminded of Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, but all I kept thinking was how desperately this composer wanted to imitate that duo. Like you said, it felt anachronistic, which didn't complement other elements of the movie that felt very committed to transporting us to that time period. As for the cinematography, it's certainly was beautiful (if a bit too digital perhaps) but sometimes only that. The cutaways to those vivid, desolate landscapes really only felt like an excuse to flaunt how beautiful the photography could be. It added nothing thematic to my sense of the story or these characters. I also wasn't a fan of splitting the plot into two timelines. They should have stuck in the trenches to avoid disrupting the lived-in experience of the soldiers.
That being said, I did really like the performances and a lot of the battle sequences. Albrecht Schuch was the standout for me.
Why do war movies always have to be so damn long? I thought the German film was good, but it seemed like it would never end.
Nice review and great movie. It will be the winner of Best International picture, undoubtely. And sadly it will surpass Spain as the third more awarded foreign country with 21 nominations and 4 wins. And please you have to correct the statistics of Spain in the predictions sections Till now they are 20 nominations (not 19) and four wins for Spain. If Alcarrás get the nomination (unlikely in my opinion), it will be a tie in thrid place between Germany and Spain with 21 nominations and 4 wins. I think that the film also can be in the conversation for adapted screenplay, art direction , sound and make-up nominations.
https://flip.it/STsIBn
https://flip.it/vAFLmJ
https://flip.it/lrjGXB
https://flip.it/I1J_o0
https://flip.it/8uJP5i
https://flip.it/yHFBjf
https://flip.it/drZsld
https://flip.it/rlZ2rs
https://flip.it/ZfyTba
https://flip.it/SwtWSz
https://flip.it/ztNQtQ
https://flip.it/6BaJ3J
https://flip.it/P_CRYu
https://flip.it/c7pzjs
https://flip.it/nxCBlp
https://flip.it/YrjN0n
https://flip.it/nOIOVa
https://flip.it/nBiEzp
https://flip.it/WA4Fyf
https://flip.it/6KePo5
https://flip.it/RUjmEj
https://flip.it/XnEzj2
https://flip.it/rZSg2a
https://flip.it/zzOvJB
https://flip.it/9GZCoA
https://flip.it/GRKQjf
https://flip.it/Vj8TCj
https://flip.it/E-addu
https://flip.it/vpiMWy
https://flip.it/V8oB0Z
https://flip.it/4lJCmH
https://flip.it/CG5TXj
https://flip.it/MbfRJl
https://flip.it/y_UfB5
https://flip.it/8TEHUS
https://flip.it/3HsXtn
https://flip.it/rrnZ69
https://flip.it/Bo0Zr_
https://flip.it/x-Iy2Q
https://flip.it/AXnuXq
https://flip.it/rpgA-T
https://flip.it/vxnelV
https://flip.it/PmhJGK
https://flip.it/qZ_0.0
https://flip.it/VWRXFz
https://flip.it/Z46qnF
https://flip.it/qYgNc3
https://flip.it/Vm2Alx
https://flip.it/tADfrz
https://flip.it/bcFqOB
https://flip.it/szb8fL
https://flip.it/tajRiL
https://flip.it/OEzTAC
https://flip.it/JcGLK2
https://flip.it/cvTx8r
https://flip.it/FRdxJT
https://flip.it/wHUNxI
https://flip.it/RzE7_f
https://flip.it/dc06jF
https://flip.it/6n1YQU
https://flip.it/fERzQ6
https://flip.it/v_udCB
https://flip.it/4VGEkw
https://flip.it/O5oOXR
https://flip.it/Z2Oa51
https://flip.it/G6XWEA
https://flip.it/.6pSWn
https://flip.it/ss7yQf
https://flip.it/XlYwTp
https://flip.it/sfnazl
https://flip.it/_g548d
https://flip.it/NIJ7vm
https://flip.it/tLNAqX
https://flip.it/0Ba174
https://flip.it/jn85Ui
https://flip.it/jn85Ui
https://sco.lt/6R0Kxs
https://sco.lt/9MfcDA
https://sco.lt/5ue48W
https://sco.lt/6A2nwW
https://sco.lt/8nXkrg
https://sco.lt/6hBTNY
https://sco.lt/6YAi00
https://sco.lt/5mCV16
https://sco.lt/7oEOlk
https://sco.lt/6dZ5TE
https://sco.lt/5go7Xs
https://sco.lt/56TStc
https://sco.lt/7iq1IW
https://sco.lt/6cQgwy
https://sco.lt/5jvhya
https://sco.lt/520Hb6
https://sco.lt/6BXCNM
https://sco.lt/8aUCsi
https://sco.lt/5L1PJQ
https://sco.lt/5YrLu4
https://sco.lt/7atFei
https://sco.lt/8EPtWC
https://sco.lt/8G35W4
https://sco.lt/5S7NZ2
https://sco.lt/7pRC4W
https://sco.lt/64RE7k
https://sco.lt/5DZR9E
https://sco.lt/6xR0Zk
https://sco.lt/85KjM8
https://sco.lt/62AR5E
https://sco.lt/7YOzDc
https://sco.lt/65ZLay
https://sco.lt/8PlZfk
https://sco.lt/5QTuW8
https://sco.lt/67GwNM
https://sco.lt/91np6O
https://sco.lt/5ST6Qa
https://sco.lt/6ydWpU
https://sco.lt/5oKDRY
https://sco.lt/8ooftw
https://sco.lt/9JBkoq
https://sco.lt/7ugUvg
https://sco.lt/9LAwjI
https://sco.lt/8kqI52
https://sco.lt/7tyV6W
https://sco.lt/4oA3xQ
https://sco.lt/8D8QNs
https://sco.lt/69y86y
https://sco.lt/54hCHg
https://sco.lt/8ZYjey
https://sco.lt/71GJma
https://sco.lt/5oKDRY
https://sco.lt/71GJma
https://sco.lt/9HCYuO
https://sco.lt/8t93dQ
https://sco.lt/6XoR2O
https://sco.lt/7Efrg8
https://sco.lt/5T2Igi
https://sco.lt/8yXR6e
https://sco.lt/7VhnU0
https://sco.lt/6sOLy4
https://sco.lt/7UDP3A
https://sco.lt/8Yqjpo
https://sco.lt/7gLkrQ
https://sco.lt/56bzPc
https://sco.lt/9BoBRA
https://sco.lt/6YJEW0
https://sco.lt/5efr1M
https://sco.lt/576mtE
https://sco.lt/7v6tcm
https://sco.lt/798gds
https://sco.lt/4l2TWi
https://sco.lt/5yTNLM
https://sco.lt/9BAaOW
https://sco.lt/7fZMFk
https://pin.it/4Bd2cjI
https://pin.it/37v6rPu
https://pin.it/57ohKSb
https://pin.it/6ALadEC
https://pin.it/6E3zXzo
https://pin.it/26DfKGo
https://pin.it/2PEYhU8
https://pin.it/6ki1h1M
https://pin.it/6YVBj2c
https://pin.it/6RIYvyq
https://pin.it/1rjE7iP
https://pin.it/4PHNyiy
https://pin.it/1CAqHRx
https://pin.it/6tUr28S
https://pin.it/5IHfwzN
https://pin.it/4N7ehWc
https://pin.it/2SaiZOm
https://pin.it/3eIdNYQ
https://pin.it/3DlXIcd
https://pin.it/5YSCnKz
https://pin.it/4GTfDS9
https://pin.it/5LIAiDE
https://pin.it/lhrGpyz
https://pin.it/aWqXXP6
https://pin.it/6xRJpOJ
https://pin.it/D4QgJUI
https://pin.it/6PKXxdF
https://pin.it/2Tj5V1z
https://pin.it/24ZUIc4
https://pin.it/aWqXXP6
https://pin.it/4SCjGD3
https://pin.it/7A47ft7
https://pin.it/64aovwD
https://pin.it/6Zb4XVV
https://pin.it/6QAyES6
https://pin.it/7tJeOSl
https://pin.it/7rGLtsm
https://pin.it/2VENjYv
https://pin.it/5nAzMTQ
https://pin.it/15dAI2f
https://pin.it/4SsZ5gE
https://pin.it/5Vjg5Gz
https://pin.it/3syPMyK
https://pin.it/4RAcOl4
https://pin.it/2GFRhXi
https://pin.it/5N4i3yX
https://pin.it/4iiOa93
https://pin.it/3qru5Yi
https://pin.it/6clVwAy
https://pin.it/6KeCI0m
https://pin.it/4YnN59m
https://pin.it/4AKpYOK
https://pin.it/2k4PfCe
https://pin.it/3Af3CfU
https://pin.it/78mzNyQ
https://pin.it/3sLCtq0
https://pin.it/6imEGi9
https://pin.it/5jUEERw
https://pin.it/31KBEqc
https://pin.it/5oAyB4o
https://pin.it/67WKcXd
https://pin.it/1TOmjP7
https://pin.it/7ojtWTa
https://pin.it/61SDT7k
https://pin.it/7qK0jXy
https://pin.it/72jYkYH
https://pin.it/2KGvNMG
https://pin.it/6Z4qIaq
https://pin.it/Eku5hNq
https://pin.it/6wtthnk
https://pin.it/31TWH8t
https://pin.it/7ufYXqr
https://pin.it/6riL4Ng
https://pin.it/1Wuz9Ws
https://pin.it/26ZM74y