DGA Nominees: Field, Kosinski, McDonagh, Spielberg, and The Daniels
Friday, January 13, 2023 at 4:00PM by Nathaniel R
Todd Field and Cate Blanchett for "Tar". Photo by Matt Licari/Invision/AP
The Directors Guild of America released their nominations yesterday. In their main Oscar-correlative prize they hewed very close to what is seen as the "top five" for Oscar's Best Picture race. Historically speaking, in a counter-intuitive twist, the DGA nominations each year have a closer correlation to eventual Best Picture nominations than the Best Director shortlist. That was of course easier to notice before the new world of the "Expanded Best Picture" lineup of the past 14 years. The exception to this general principle of 'if it's up for the DGA it'll be up for Best Picture' certainty is the nomination for Todd Field for TÁR. While the film has a great shot at making the 10 wide Best Picture list, it's not generally considered one of the top five contenders and could theoretically be snubbed still, given that more than 10 films still seem plausible as contenders. As a result Field is looking very strong in Best Director as the Academy votes on their nominations this week...
OUTSTANDING DIRECTOR, THEATRICAL FEATURE
- Todd Field (1st nomination) TÁR
- Joseph Kosinski (1st nomination) Top Gun Maverick
- Daniel Kwan & Daniel Scheinert (1st nomination) Everything Everywhere All At Once
- Martin McDonagh (2nd nomination) The Banshees of Inisherin
- Steven Spielberg (13th nomination / 3 wins / 1 Lifetime Achievement Award) The Fabelmans
While Todd Field has 3 Oscar nominations under his belt (2 for Adapted Screenplay, 1 for Picture) he has yet to be nominated for direction. TÁR could well change that. Likewise Martin McDonagh has been up for 4 Oscars (winning for Short Film) but he has yet to score as a Director despite receiving a previous DGA nod (for Three Billboards). If McDonagh is nominated for the Oscar in this category, he'll only be the second Best Live Action Short Film winner to ever "graduate" to a Best Director nod; the only previous person to do it is Taylor Hackford who won for Teenage Father (1978) before his Oscar nomination for directing Ray (2004)
Though there are anomalous years like the chaos of 2012 when only TWO directing guild nominees landed Oscar noms, most years line up 4/5 so it's likely that only one of them is vulnerable come Oscar nomination morning. But which one. It's not always the one you think that gets the drop.
OUTSTANDING DIRECTOR, FIRST TIME FEATURE
- Alice Diop, Saint Omer
- Audrey Diwan, Happening
- John Patton Ford, Emily the Criminal
- Antoneta Alamat Kusijanovic, Murina
- Charlotte Wells, Aftersun
It's immediately noticeable that the list is 80% women (whereas the main category is 100% men) which speaks to how rapidly things have been changing behind the scenes in cinema, with more and more female directors getting work. In other news, it's been heartening to see the embrace of Happening, more than a year after we first fell in love with it at Venice in 2021. In hindsight it now feels like it could have been a force in Best International Feature Film last season had France submitted it rather than Titane.
Charlotte Wells has been such an awards magnet for "Debut Director" prizes this year that we wouldn't be completely shocked to see her in the Oscar lineup for Best Director, IF they decide to stray beyond Best Picture contenders.
Reader Comments (8)
Absolutely thrilled by Field’s semi-surprise DGA nod. Every DGA nominee in the last ten years has gone on to a Best Picture Oscar nod. That said, I’m still a tad nervous for TÁR in Best Picture. There’s just so many comparisons to CAROL’s awards run (respected, highbrow, Cate Blanchett led drama showered with critic awards but robbed of an expected Best Picture Oscar nom while being perceived as too “chilly”. What gives me hope is TÁR managed BOTH PGA and DGA nods (whereas CAROL got neither). And with industry titans like Marin Scorsese raving about it, TÁR will obviously score #1 votes on ballots. While there’s a minor chance it could go the way of FOXCATCHER or ANOTHER ROUND and score a Best Directing bid without a Best Picture nom, every film that has won the critics trifecta (NYFCC, LAFCA, NSFC) has gone on to a Best Picture Oscar nomination. If something as “challenging” as DRIVE MY CAR can make the final ten, I think TÁR can too.
I think all five of these are safe now. Since the expansion of Best Picture, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is the only film to miss a Best Picture nod despite getting in at the Director's Guild.
But I do think Oscar's Best Directing lineup is gonna be wild and only Spielberg is safe.
TAR is such a director's piece and Field has Scorsese in his corner championing him,i'll be shocked if he misses.
The two I wouldn't bet money on for Oscar nods are The Daniels and Kosinski. The former might be two young and irreverent for the stolid Directors Branch and the latter could be dismissed as the director of a Bruckheimer sequel.
And was I the only one who wondered who that homeless man was who crashed the Globes only to realize it was Jerry Bruckheimer?
While I’m really not a fan of Kwan/Scheinert & McDonagh’s nominations, at least it’s not Baz Luhrmann. What a travesty it’ll be if Luhrmann makes it into Oscar’s lineup over so many FAR more deserving directors.
I always love seeing the First Time nominees, although it’s disappointing that there is no excitement allowed anymore for that category. Much like the acting categories, these days only 1 person is allowed to win at every single awards show. So DGA will no doubt give it to Charlotte Wells because, well, everyone else did. Why have other nominees when it’s so obvious no one else is allowed to win?
There is an issue with first time directors. I am French, and I could be delighted by the inclusion of Saint Omer and Happening but Alice Diop has directed documentaries before, including one released in theaters, and Audrey Diwan also directed a previous feature film. Could they be eliminated ? Weird it is not being noticed at all
I've thought for awhile now that TAR would get the "international director" slot in the directing five at the Oscars. Of course I know that Field is not int'l himself. But, TAR is set in Germany and more importantly, the tone and style is international vibes.
I don't think Spielberg is as safe as people think...